Choosing a Scythe cooler for Intel E6420

1 reply [Last post]
DeadnightWarrior's picture
Joined: 08/31/2008
Posts: 3

Hello all,
I'm fairly new to overclocking and I'd like a suggestion.
I know my Intel Core2Duo E6420 CPU is quite capable of running at least at 2.6 Ghz (vs. its 2.13 Ghz default speed) but when I tried to overclock it, it would only be stable at 2.33 Ghz. Anything above that speed resulted in a system crash.
I'm buying a better case, with a couple of 120 mm fans for air circulation (the case I'm using now is a very low budget product with no additional fans). Next, I'd like to replace the stock Intel cooler with a better one, but nothing over the top.
In the end, I'm interested in two Scythe coolers but can't decide which one is best for my purpose: the Shuriken rev. B or the Samurai ZZ. Both have a very affordable price tag, look solid, claim to be very quiet and support an average overclock.
Which one would you suggest?
Please keep in mind that my main concern is getting the CPU to run safely at 2.6 Ghz (or even above that, if possible!) but I'd also like a cooler that doesn't sound like a tornado.

My PC specs are as follows:
- Gigabyte GA-P35-S3 motherboard (Intel P35, rev. 1.0, latest BIOS installed) -> details
- Intel E6420 CPU -> details
- 2 x 2 Gb DDR2 Kingmax Mars
- ATI HD3870 512 Mb (reference design - could be replaced with an HD5770)
- Maxtor DiamondMax 10, 200 Gb SATA (will be replaced with a WD Caviar Black, 640 Gb)
- Hiper 530W PSU
- generic ATX midi tower case (will be replaced with a Cooler Master Elite 334)

Thank you for your help :)

Tiv's picture
Joined: 08/12/2009
Posts: 3584

Don't waste your money on either of those coolers. If I had to pick between the two I'd not get the Samurai ZZ because the heat pipes will bend. But the Shuriken rev. B is easily bested by other cheap coolers in that price range.

XIGMATEK HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle CPU Cooler $34.99

If it was my system I'd probably install a Thermalright TRUE with two Noctua fans for a push pull.

Noctua NH-U9B SE2 92mm SSO CPU Cooler

I sleep fine at night knowing we are banning people who deserve it.  Tivon
Don't test my skills, I was trained by myself! Check out my Gaming Videos!