Caviar blacks vs. Caviar green

7 replies [Last post]
david179057
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2012
Posts: 208

should i go toward a 1 tb black or a 2 tb green for the same price?

how fast is a black over a green?

Asus P8P67 Deluxe : i7 2600k : Corsair Vengeance 8 GB 1600
Asus GTX 560 Direct Cu II OC : Corsair H100
Kingston Hyper X 3K 120 GB : WD Caviar Black 1 TB : Windows 7 Home Premium
OCZ ZT 750W PSU : CM 690 II

limeDk
limeDk's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/22/2011
Posts: 124

if for storage then take the Green if for system "windows and stuff" then the Black

Razear
Razear's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/30/2008
Posts: 1116

It depends on your needs. If you want the fastest performance, go with the Black drive. If you're using it for storage, go for the Green drive. The performance difference between the two is relatively large, the Black preforms notably faster.

Prophet4NO1
Offline
Joined: 09/13/2010
Posts: 196

I can tell you from a retail side of things, we get WAY more WD Green drives back than any other we sell at the Microcenter I work at. They are junk drives. If you just need data storage get the LP/Green drives from Seagate. Much lower return/failure rate. The WD Blacks are ok, but we get more of them back than anything from Seagate or Samsung. Hitachi is the other crap drive across the board. I used to only buy and recommend WD, but after this whole flood thing, build quality has gone in the toilet. Might be better down the road once they are back up to speed and get that plant that was destroyed rebuilt.

david179057
Offline
Joined: 01/15/2012
Posts: 208

i found what i was looking for but thanks for the advise guys. im getting the black

http://www.legitreviews.com/article/1077/8/

3dGameMan
3dGameMan's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/31/2000
Posts: 5054

Rodney Reynolds,
Register: http://www.3dgameman.com/user/register

jeremchoo
Offline
Joined: 03/28/2010
Posts: 2

hi there i have a problem, just bought brand new wd green 2tb sata 3 64mb cache.
i have it plugged into a sata 2 port and the hdd started to make a noise and nothing shows on the bios.
i tried to see what jumper settings should the hdd work. on ssc there is no noise. on phy mode noise.on default no jumper noise. i am thinking there is a problem with the hdd

Rodney please advise

i also bought a wd black caviar for work server will try the green hdd on sata 3 port

JeremCHOO

eire1274
eire1274's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/12/2003
Posts: 1147

A noisy drive with no controller response indicates that the drive is bad out of the box.

Green drives are cheaper, but they are also less demanding on power with their rapid sleep response, and equally better on heat output. If the drive sleeps, the spindle doesn't spin, and that is the major source of heat on a mechanical hard disk. My advice is for in-system drives, avoid them and stick with the blacks or better for the better reliability and the drive transfer speeds. In RAID environments with data mirroring (RAID 1, 1+0 [often mis-referred to as RAID 10], 5, 6, or RAID-Z / FlexRAID) they are fairly safe as a disk failure won't kill the data, and the chances of two failures at once is slim. Speed isn't as much of a concern in RAID levels either, especially if you are using a larger group of drives.

By the way, SSC is Spread Spectrum Clocking. SSC is used to reduce magnetic interference, but it does hamper the signal quality and can cause controller read errors. Very similar to Spread Spectrum in the BIOS which can cause strange PC issues. PHY refers to Physical Layer and in most cases slows down the RW speeds to original SATA, 1.5Gb/s, and shouldn't ever be used unless an old controller can't identify the drive correctly.

Nick McDermott